Welcome Mr. Mehta, What can do I for you ?” said Jenny, a relationship manager working with a leading private sector bank, to the bank customer Mr. Mehta, who himself is a tax consultant.

“I just wanted to deposit these cheques to my account” said Mr. Mehta.

“That will be done Sir. And I would also like to tell you something about a very good tax saving product which will give you insurance as well as good returns.” Said Jenny.

“Is it another ULIP you are talking about Jenny?” asked Mr. Mehta.

“Sir, this is a very good product specially designed for people like you.” Was Jenny’s confused reply to a straight question.

“ Yes, but is it a ULIP?” Mr. Mehta asked firmly this time.

“Yes Sir”. Jenny had no alternative than to confess this time. “But you need to pay the premium only for 5 years”

“Ok. But do you know that as per the draft DTC, the contribution made towards ULIP might not qualify for tax saving. So in effect, it would be mandatory for me to pay the premium for this ULIP for 5 years and invest separately for saving tax.” Asked Mr. Mehta.

“No Sir, when you are buying a ULIP now, the Company is entering into a contract with you that it will give you tax benefit for 5 years. So, DTC or no-DTC, you will continue getting a tax deduction on the premium paid towards this ULIP.” Said Jenny.

“Are you Sure?” Mr. Mehta was astonished. “Is it a Company that decides whether you get a tax deduction or the Government decides it?”

“The Company” Jenny said in a low and hesitant tone.

Mr. Mehta stared at her with anger and surprise, when Deepa,a colleague of Jenny, came to her rescue, saying, “Sir, you are right, it is the government that gives a tax deduction and not the company.”

“Yes, and thus, I would like to wait till the time there is clarity on this one, and only then I would commit myself to such a product wherein I need to compulsorily pay for next 5 years. Had it been a one-time invest product, like an ELSS, I would have definitely invested in it.” Said Mr. Mehta.

Jenny was little disappointed. But she didn’t give up so easily.

“Mr. Mehta, you also have an HUF account with us. Don’t you?” She asked.

“I do. So?” said Mr. Mehta.

“You might be aware that the tax saving limit u/s 80C is Rs. 2 Lakhs for HUF accounts.So you can make some tax saving investments from that acco” Said Jenny.

“What??” Mr. Mehta was really angry by now. “Ms. Jenny, just for your information, I am myself a tax consultant, and would like to update you that the tax saving limit for HUFs is the same as individuals, which is Rs. 1 Lakh u/s 80C and Rs. 20,000 u/s 80CCF.”

“Ohh is it?? But I remember ‘SOMEONE’ telling me that the tax saving limit for an HUF is Rs. 2 Lakhs” Jenny was shaken by now.

“SOMEONE ??? And who is that SOMEONE ?? Ma’am, you are a responsible officer in a reputed bank. People from non-finance background trust your words like anything, and you have no other business than to mis-guide people. Thankfully, I am a tax consultant myself, or else you would have successfully cheated me. Are you a Banker or a Cheater?” said the fuming Mr. Mehta.

Jenny had a simple escape route. She just had to apologize and say that she will recheck these things. But on his way back from the bank, Mr. Mehta was thinking, “Times have now come that even your banker might not be shy of cheating you. Do your homework before trusting his words blindly.”

So beware of all such “Jennys” when you visit your bank next time.

We look forward to your feedback and comments on the above article. Please feel free to contact us on saurabh@nidhiinvestments.com if you have any questions.

(The views mentioned in the article are personal opinion of the author. The characters used in the article are real and names are changed for protection of identity.)


  1. A close to heart Article !! I could actually imagine the entire scene happening in front of me. Everytime I visit the bank, something of this sort happens and I end up investing in something they sell, thinking that how can my banker lie ??

    Need to be careful from now. Thanks to Prof bajaj.

    1. Thanks for the compliments Sir.

      This is actually a real story and it keeps happening with so many of us everyday.

      Thats why I thought I should bring these facts to light. Glad to know that you liked it.

      Thanks for your visit and feedback. Looking forward to more in future.

  2. Nothing else can describe the true nature of so called bank’s ‘Relationship Manager’ as described in this article. Suprisingly, specially in private banks, first line customer facing ‘executives’ don’t have knowledge of banking, laws even policies of their own banks.
    Everytime someone from bank calls and say I am your new relationship manager and want to meet you. First few times gave them time and all they did was trying to sell ‘Insurance / Investment’ (read ULIP) and have to time to understand my investment needs. I stopped entertaining them.
    Life is not long enough to make all mistakes, either you learn by experience or reading Professor’s blog.

    1. Very well Said Sir.

      All these So-called “Relationship Managers” are no less than sophisticated Cheaters well trained (read ill-trained) to cheat you.

      One needs to be aware of these “Cheaters”.

      Thank you so much for the compliments and I will make sure that I am able to keep up to your expectations. THanks again for your visit and feedback. Looking forward to more in future.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s